xTool P2 vs P2S vs P3: CO2 Lasers Compared
Share
I've run an xTool P2 since 2023. I don't own the P2S or P3, so everything about those two comes from xTool's own published pages, and I'll say when it's my P2 experience talking. The xTool links here are affiliate links, and xTool has never had a say in what I write.
xTool's CO2 lineup comes down to three machines right now: the P2 I've used for years, the P2S that replaced it, and the P3 flagship. They look similar in photos, but they're pretty different machines. This post lays them side by side and tells you which one I'd point you to for different kinds of work.
The short version
P2S for most desktop shops. P3 when you've outgrown a desktop bed. P2 only as a refurb deal.
xTool P2S
The current 55W desktop CO2. Same size and laser as my P2, with faster engraving, better airflow and easier optics cleaning.
xTool P3
80W, 915 x 458 mm, a built-in lift base and Class 1 safety. A production machine that needs floor space.
xTool P2
Not sold new anymore. xTool sells it refurbished when it has stock. Still a capable machine.
Side by side
These are xTool's published numbers. The P2 and P2S are listed side by side on xTool's own P2S page, and the P3 page compares itself to the P2S.
| P2 | P2S | P3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Laser | 55W CO2 | 55W CO2 | 80W CO2, optional 5W IR |
| Working area | 600 x 305 mm | 600 x 305 mm | 915 x 458 mm |
| Max height | 64 mm with tray, 215 mm with riser | 64 mm with tray, 215 mm with riser | 220 mm, lift base built in |
| Max speed | 600 mm/s | 600 mm/s | 1,200 mm/s |
| X-axis acceleration | 3,200 mm/s² | 6,400 mm/s² | 19,600 mm/s² |
| One-pass cut | 18 mm basswood, 20 mm acrylic | 18 mm basswood, 20 mm acrylic | 20 mm basswood, 25 mm acrylic |
| Cameras | 16MP panoramic + close-range | 16MP panoramic + close-range | 16MP panoramic + close-range + 2 side |
| Positioning | 0.3 mm | 0.3 mm | 0.2 mm |
| Safety class | Class 4 | Class 4 | Class 1, built-in fire suppression |
| Size and weight | 1000 x 639 x 268 mm, 45 kg | 1000 x 639 x 268 mm, 45 kg | 1250 x 780 x 496 mm, 105 kg |
| Software xTool lists | xTool software, LightBurn | xTool Studio, LightBurn without camera or autofocus | xTool Studio |
| Availability | Refurbished only | Current | Current |
P2 vs P2S: what changed
On xTool's own spec table, the P2 and P2S match almost row for row. The differences xTool calls out are double the X-axis acceleration (it says engraving gets about 40% faster), a stronger exhaust fan and air pump, an optical path solution for easier cleaning, and new software features like 3D cylinder engraving and Batch Processing 2.0.
The cleaning change is the one I'd care about most. I clean the lens and mirrors on my P2 every day, and it takes about five minutes once you've done it a few times. Anything that makes that faster adds up over a year.
If you find a refurbished P2 at the right price and you're fine with a shorter warranty, it's still a capable machine. Mine has cut and engraved signs, slate coasters, acrylic and a stack of test cards since 2023. New, the P2S is the one to buy.
P2S vs P3: a different class of machine
This isn't a small step. On xTool's numbers, the P3 has 45% more laser power, double the top speed, three times the X-axis acceleration and about 2.3 times the bed area. It also carries a lift base, a water chiller and fire suppression that the P2S doesn't have built in.
- Height. The P2S is 64 mm tall with the tray. Anything taller needs the riser base, sold separately. The P3's motorized lift base gives you 220 mm out of the box. I run a Thunder Nova 35 with a motorized bed too, and not having to swap in a riser is a real convenience.
- Safety. xTool rates the P3 Class 1 with IR flame sensors, a temperature sensor, side cameras and built-in CO2 fire suppression. The P2S is Class 4, and fire suppression is an optional kit.
- Metal. Neither marks bare metal on the CO2 alone. The P3 offers an optional 5W IR module that xTool says adds bare stainless steel and aluminum.
- Space. The P3 is 105 kg and 1250 mm wide. The P2S is 45 kg. Plan a stand and a second person for the P3.
Which one I'd point you to
Get the P2S if
- You're buying your first CO2 or replacing a diode
- Your work fits in 600 x 305 mm, or passthrough handles the long pieces
- You want camera placement in a desktop footprint
- You'd like to keep LightBurn as an option
Get the P3 if
- You're running production and speed is money
- You regularly work on tall items or full-size signs
- You want Class 1 safety and fire suppression built in
- You have the floor space and a stand for a 105 kg machine
Consider a refurb P2 if
- xTool has one in stock at a price that makes sense
- You're fine with a refurbished machine's shorter warranty
- You don't need the P2S's faster engraving
Whichever one you pick, the day-one list is the same: an inline duct fan venting outside, a cleaning kit, CO2 laser safety glasses rated for 10,600 nm, and your own test settings instead of the defaults.
Engraving tests across three speed ranges plus cutting tests, laid out so you can run them once, find your power and speed, and stop guessing.
Digital download. A LightBurn version is available too.
See the Test File KitSee the P2S at xToolSee the P3 at xTool (affiliate links)
Common questions
What's the difference between the xTool P2 and P2S?
Per xTool, the P2S doubles X-axis acceleration, which it says makes engraving about 40% faster, and adds a stronger exhaust fan and air pump, easier optics cleaning, 3D cylinder engraving and Batch Processing 2.0. The laser, work area, cameras and size are the same.
Is the xTool P3 worth it over the P2S?
If you need the space, height or speed, yes. The P3 has 80W, a 915 x 458 mm bed, 220 mm of height with a built-in lift base, 1,200 mm/s and Class 1 safety. If your work fits in 600 x 305 mm and 64 mm of height most of the time, the P2S covers it in a much smaller machine.
Can you still buy the xTool P2?
Not new. xTool sells the P2 as an official refurbished unit when it has stock.
Which xTool CO2 can engrave bare metal?
Only the P3, with its optional 5W IR module. On the CO2 laser alone, all three mark coated or treated metal, not bare metal.
Which xTool CO2 works with LightBurn?
xTool lists LightBurn for the P2 and P2S, and says the P2S camera and autofocus don't work in LightBurn. It lists xTool Studio for the P3. I've never gotten my own P2 working with LightBurn, so I run it in xTool's software.
Have you used all three?
No. I've run the P2 since 2023. The P2S and P3 details in this post come from xTool's published pages.
More from the Maker Guides
xTool P2: what I've learned since 2023
Sam
Disclosure: I own an xTool P2. I don't own the P2S or P3, and no hands-on testing of them is reflected in this post. xTool requested one of my P2 videos. xTool links in this post are affiliate links that may earn Samcraft a commission at no extra cost to you. xTool has no editorial input or control over Samcraft content. Samcraft sells its own test files for xTool machines. Specifications are from xTool's P2S and P3 product pages. Last reviewed September 2026.